Looking for an eyeliner that stays put all day? The NYX Epic Wear Liner Stick might be the answer you need.
This waterproof pencil comes in 33 shades, from bold mattes to glowing metallics. Satin, sheer, shimmer, and glitter finishes add even more choice.
The brand claims up to 36 hours of wear that stays fade resistant. It also skips animal testing, so you can apply it with peace of mind.
Many users say it resists smudging, even on sweaty, humid skin. The color feels rich and strong in just one swipe.
Some people wished for more product in the tube, and a few reported eyelid swelling. In this review, we will explore what works, what falls short, and who should try this liner. Keep reading to see if it earns a spot in your makeup bag.
In a Nutshell
- Animal-friendly choice: The brand does not test on animals, so animal lovers can feel good about adding this liner to their routine.
- Strong color in one pass: The pencil lays down rich, bold pigment quickly, so your lid looks polished without several layers.
- Easy for beginners: The pencil glides on smoothly, and a sharp tip helps you draw a clean line even if you are new to eyeliner.
- Simple patch test first: Try a small swipe on your inner arm before you wear it near your eyes. This helps you check how your skin reacts before a full application.
- Good rival to the liquid version: The sister product, NYX Epic Inky Stix, offers a liquid formula if you want a different texture and a sharper wing.
- Good starting point for comparison: Shoppers who love drugstore finds often compare it with Zabrena’s Battle of Drugstore liquid eyeliners to see which formula fits their daily look best.
Shade Range and Finishes
- 36 Hour Wear: NYX Professional Makeup Epic Wear Liner Sticks are powerfully pigmented eyeliner pencils that deliver 36 hours of waterproof, smudge proof, and fade proof eyeliner color; It's perfect for waterproof all day and night graphic eyeliner looks
- Matte Metallic Finished Eyeliners: Our Epic Wear Liner Sticks are powerfully pigmented eyeliner pencils available in metallic matte finished shades; These high impact eyeliner pencils go above and beyond the call for long lasting, bold color
Last update on 2026-10-30 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API Some of the links on this website are affiliate links, which means that at no additional cost to you, I earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. I only recommend products and services that I believe will add value to my readers. Thank you for your support!
The shade range offers far more than simple black. Each finish changes how your liner looks on the lid. Pick a finish first, then choose a color that suits your style.
Matte shades give a clean and sharp look. They suit everyday wear and work well for a polished office style. Matte finishes also hide small wobbles in your line.
Satin finishes sit between matte and shine. They add a soft glow without looking heavy. This option works nicely for daytime makeup and quick touch ups.
Sheer shades offer a gentle wash of color. They help you build intensity slowly. If you prefer a natural look, start with a sheer tone and layer it for more depth.
Shimmer shades catch the light when you blink or smile. They add dimension to brown and bronze tones. Press shimmer gently onto the center of the lid for a subtle lift.
Glitter finishes bring the most sparkle to your routine. They suit parties, concerts, and special evenings out. Press a glitter shade over a dark base so the sparkle really pops.
Mixing finishes can create a personal look. Try matte black along the lash line and a shimmer shade in the inner corner. This combination adds depth without extra tools.
Check each shade in daylight before you settle on one. Indoor lights can shift how a color looks on your lid. Daylight shows the true tone more clearly.
Warm undertones often pair well with bronze, copper, and plum shades. Cool undertones usually look bright with navy, silver, and icy blue. Look at the veins on your wrist to guess your undertone.
Eye color matters too. Brown eyes often glow with copper or gold. Blue eyes stand out against deep bronze or charcoal shades. Green eyes look striking with plum or burgundy.
Start with one neutral finish and one bold option. Build your collection slowly. Each shade should earn its place in your makeup bag.
Texture and Application
Texture plays a big role in how a liner feels on your skin. This pencil feels soft and creamy, so it does not tug at your lid. Your hand can move with ease.
Warm the tip first. Run the pencil over the back of your hand for a few seconds. This softens the formula so it flows more evenly.
Use short, light strokes instead of pressing hard. Pressing can drag the lid skin and create lines. Light strokes build a neat line over time.
Build the look in layers. Start with a thin line along the lash base. Then add a second layer only where you want more depth. This keeps the color even and clean.
Apply a lid primer before you draw. A primer gives the pencil a smooth base to grip. The color can look more vivid on a prepped lid.
Try a softer, smudged effect for everyday wear. Blend the line with a small flat brush or a cotton swab. The edges turn misty and feel relaxed.
Line the waterline for extra definition. A thin stroke along the lower lash line can make your lashes look fuller. Keep the pressure gentle so the delicate skin stays calm.
Clean up mistakes with care. Dip a cotton swab in micellar water and wipe away the extra color. Work slowly and use short passes. A steady hand gives the cleanest result.
Finish with a quick check in the mirror. Blink a few times and look at the line from the side. Adjust any spots that look thin or uneven.
Wear Performance and Longevity
Wear performance is a big reason people reach for this pencil. The brand claims up to 36 hours of wear, so your look can last from morning coffee to late dinner.
Real wear depends on your skin and your day. Oily lids can push color around faster, so the liner may need a little extra help.
Many shoppers say the liner stays put all day without smudging. One reviewer noted that it held its shape through a long, busy shift.
Humid weather tests every eyeliner. This pencil stays precise on sweaty skin in brand demos, which helps during summer events or workouts.
Think about the setting too. A waterproof formula handles rain, a steamy shower, or an emotional day with more confidence than a basic pencil.
Sharpen often for the best staying power. A fresh tip sets the line cleanly, and a clean base helps color hold longer.
Pair the liner with a setting spray if you want extra hold on hot days. A light mist after drawing can help the color bond to your skin.
Touch ups are simple. Keep a small brush or cotton swab nearby. Dab a little matching eyeshadow over the line if the color starts to fade.
Longer wear also depends on your routine. Remove makeup at night with a mild cleanser. Gentle cleansing keeps lash roots healthy and protects your lids from rubbing.
Lighting can change how long the look seems to last. Check your liner in natural light at midday, since dim bathroom lights can hide smudges that appear later.
Keep in mind the small amount of product inside. Because the pencil runs out fast, plan each stroke so you do not waste it.
Overall, the pencil offers strong staying power for most days. Test it on a quiet afternoon first to see how your skin handles it.
Top 3 Alternatives
Looking for a new eyeliner? These three options are worth a try. Each one offers a different feel, so you can find the best fit for your routine.
Maybelline Tattoo Liner
- Up To 24HR Lip Stain: Our Peel Off Lip Liner provides tattoo-like wear for a tinted lip blush stain effect that lasts all day. Its buildable formula glides effortlessly onto lips, offering a no transfer peel off lip stain
- Easy-Peel Off Formula: Ultra-comfortable formula with ink grip pigments and easy-peel cushion gel for up to 24 hours of stain. This lip liner formula's cushiony gel dries quickly in 5 minutes and creates an easy-peel film that peels off seamlessly
Last update on 2026-10-30 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API Some of the links on this website are affiliate links, which means that at no additional cost to you, I earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. I only recommend products and services that I believe will add value to my readers. Thank you for your support!
Maybelline Tattoo Liner gives you bold color that stays put all day. It glides on smooth and dries fast, so you can get back to your day quickly. Many people love how it resists smudging, even in humid weather.
Why people pick it: The gel formula lasts for hours without fading. It works well for a sharp wing or a soft smoky look. Your lines stay clean from morning to night.
e.l.f. Lock On Liner
- Multi-functional; use as brow color, eyeshadow, and eyeliner
- Smudge-proof and waterproof formula lasts all day
Last update on 2026-10-30 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API Some of the links on this website are affiliate links, which means that at no additional cost to you, I earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. I only recommend products and services that I believe will add value to my readers. Thank you for your support!
e.l.f. Lock On Liner offers a creamy texture with strong pigment. You can apply it in one swipe for a crisp line. The formula stays in place through a busy day.
Best for: Beginners who want easy results. The fine tip helps you draw small details near the lash line. You can also build more color with a second layer.
Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner
- LASTING EYELINER: Rich color looks freshly applied all day long; transfer-proof, waterproof, smudge-proof and fade-proof
- UP TO 24HR WEAR: Creates the look you want and stays on strong
Last update on 2026-06-01 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API Some of the links on this website are affiliate links, which means that at no additional cost to you, I earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. I only recommend products and services that I believe will add value to my readers. Thank you for your support!
Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner comes in a pencil style that feels soft on the lids. It blends well with a smudger for a smoky finish. The formula holds its shape without tugging at sensitive skin.
Good to know: Sharpen the pencil before each use. A sharp tip keeps your line thin and neat. You can also use it on the waterline for a bold, defined look.
Skin Sensitivity and Safety
Sensitive eyes need extra care. The skin around the eyes is thin and delicate. Some people react to pigments, waxes, or other ingredients in eyeliner pencils.
One shopper reported eyelid swelling after using this stick. Reactions like this are uncommon, but they deserve attention. Stop using the product if you notice swelling, itching, or burning.
Try a patch test first. Draw a small line on the inner arm or behind the ear. Wait at least 24 hours and check for redness, bumps, or dryness. Only use the liner near your eyes if your skin stays calm.
Clean tools help protect your skin. Bacteria can build up on the pencil tip and on your sharpener. Wipe the tip with a clean tissue before each use. Avoid sharing your pencil with friends, even when they ask nicely.
Replace the pencil on time. Old liners can collect germs and dry out. Most makeup experts suggest replacing eye pencils every few months. Write the opening date on the packaging so you can track it easily.
Waterproof formulas need gentle removal. Rubbing hard can irritate the lash line and the skin beneath it. Hold a soaked pad against your lashes for a few seconds, then wipe slowly. Your eyes will thank you.
Be careful near the waterline if your eyes burn easily. This area holds more moisture and can react faster to new products. Start with a light touch and stop if you feel any stinging.
Talk to a doctor when symptoms last. If swelling, redness, or itching does not fade within a day, contact a dermatologist or eye doctor. Contact lens wearers should check with their eye care provider before they try any new liner.
Value and Product Quantity
Quantity is a big question for many shoppers. The stick holds a small amount of product. One user said it ran out quickly, so plan your use from the start.
Think about how often you wear eyeliner. A daily wearer will go through a pencil faster than someone who only wears liner for special events. Track your use for two weeks to see how fast the pencil shrinks.
Pick your shades with care. The range includes 33 matte and metallic shades, plus other finishes. Choose one everyday shade, such as black or brown, and save bright colors for special days. This way, your favorite shade lasts longer.
Store the pencil with the cap on. Heat and air can dry out the formula. A cool spot away from sunny windows or a hot bathroom works well.
Stop using the stick when the tip becomes too dry to glide. Pressing harder on a dry tip wastes product and can irritate the lash line.
Never share your eyeliner with friends. Shared pencils can spread bacteria and cause eye infections. Each person should own their own pencil.
Plan ahead to avoid running out at the wrong time. Count your wear days each month. This helps you know when to restock before your favorite shade runs dry.
Pros and Cons
Pros
- Powerfully pigmented, so one swipe gives bold color
- Cruelty-free formula with no animal testing involved
- Waterproof pencil that suits people who want a long-lasting line
- Works for both everyday looks and bolder night looks
- Offers many finishes for different styles and moods
Cons
- Most praise for wear comes from user reviews and brand demos
- Long-term results are not backed by broad independent testing
- People with very sensitive eyes should choose this pencil with care
Who Should Buy It
Not every makeup lover needs the same eyeliner. This pencil suits some people better than others. Here is who may enjoy it most.
Beginners often feel more relaxed with a pencil. A pencil feels familiar and easy to control. New users can practice their lines without much pressure.
Experimenters can have fun with the shade range. You can mix finishes to build new looks each week. A matte shade on the lower lash line with a metallic shade on the lid can create real depth.
Party lovers may enjoy the glitter and shimmer options. These shades work well for nights out, festivals, and photo days. Try a glitter shade over a dark base for a bold, glowing finish.
People who like quick routines may appreciate the simple process. You draw the line, blend if you want, and head out the door. Less fuss can mean more time for the rest of your day.
Frequent travelers may like keeping one in their bag. A single pencil takes little room and fits easily in a makeup pouch. It can help you feel ready for a last minute trip.
Some people should look elsewhere. Professional makeup artists who need many color changes each day may prefer a larger kit. Shoppers who go through liner very quickly may want a bigger backup supply.
Ask yourself a few honest questions first. Think about how often you reach for liner and what look you want most. Your answers will show you if this stick fits your daily life.
Final Verdict
Is this eyeliner worth a spot in your makeup bag?
The NYX Epic Wear Liner Stick earns a solid place for most makeup fans. It gives reliable color that stays put through a busy day.
Its biggest strength is consistency. Many liners promise a lot but skip, drag, or fade halfway through the day. This pencil usually does what it says.
That reliability matters most when you want a look that needs no touch ups. You can leave the house and trust your eyes to look the same at dinner.
Still, it may not suit everyone. Some people want a larger supply, and others may react to certain ingredients. Watch how your skin feels after the first few wears.
Think of it as a dependable everyday tool. It works best in a routine you already enjoy. It does not replace a full range of eye products.
Compare it with other options before you commit. NYX Epic Inky Stix offers a different feel. Zabrena liquid liners suit people who want a sharper, brush based line.
Who should choose it? Pick this pencil if you want strong color, steady wear, and an easy process. Skip it if you need a large supply or if eye products irritate you quickly.
Try one shade first before you build a full collection. Wear it for a few days and notice how it feels on your lids. That short test often tells you more than any review can.
Your eye shape, skin type, and daily plans all shape the result. Choose the finish that matches your style and schedule, and you will likely enjoy the outcome.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I remove the NYX Epic Wear Liner Stick at the end of the day?
Waterproof pencils need a little extra help to come off. Use an oil-based makeup remover on a cotton pad. Hold it on the lid for a few seconds, then wipe gently from the inner corner outward.
Is the NYX Epic Wear Liner Stick the same as NYX Epic Inky Stix?
They are separate products, but both come from NYX. Compare their finishes and how they feel on your lid before you choose one.
Should I test it on my skin before the first full use?
Yes, a small test is a smart move. Draw a thin line near your lash line on a day with no plans. Stop using it if you notice redness, itching, or swelling.
How can I keep the tip clean and easy to control?
Wipe the tip with a clean tissue between lines. Keep the cap on tight when you are not using it. This helps the pencil stay ready for your next look.
What should I do if the pencil runs out quickly?
Track how often you reach for it. Save it for nights out and special looks, and use a backup liner for daily wear. This keeps your favorite shade going much longer.
